“So … what can you eat?”

Ah, the age-old question. When someone finds out that you’re gluten intolerant and can’t eat dairy, you can almost see their brain quickly scrolling through the list of foods they love that contain those forbidden ingredients, “Error” and “Does Not Compute” messages popping up all over the place. After they shake their confusion and provide an anecdote about their third cousin, twice removed who is gluten intolerant, they inevitably ask, “So … what can you eat?”

My answer to the question is usually “water” at first, which gets a few chuckles, but I answer that way because the question is actually difficult for me. In reality, I can eat whatever I want. If I want mac and cheese, I will find a way to make “mac and cheese.” If I am craving a Crunchwrap Supreme from Taco Bell, I will create a Crunchwrap Supreme. If I need some gooey, chocolatey brownies, I will get my dang brownies!

Sure, these foods aren’t “the real thing” to normal people, but the gluten free+ diet is all about substitutions. Can’t eat something? Substitute it! I know, I know—the texture, aroma, and flavor will not be exactly the same as the “real” thing, but a close replica is better than no replica, right?

Below is my list of my favorite substitutions. Use this for yourself and share this with your normal friends. Nothing is worse than having a lovely, kind friend who has baked, cooked, or bought food specifically for you, only for you to have to break the news to them that you can’t eat it. They were just so excited because they saw the word “vegan” on the label; they didn’t realize that it had whole wheat flour in it.*

*Note: Just because I generally eat healthier than the average human, does not mean that I always want healthy foods that are whole grain, paleo, keto, Whole30, low glycemic index, sirtfood, fat-free, and sugar-free. Bring on the full-fat, refined sugar-filled desserts, baby!

Vegan/Dairy Free Substitutes (all are also gluten free!)

Butter Earth Balance
(this is exactly like butter—I can’t even tell the difference anymore)
Oil Olive oil
Coconut oil
Sesame oil
Avocado oil
Vegetable oil
Milk Coconut milk
Almond milk
Soy milk
Cheese/YogurtDaiya (cheeze shreds, blocks, or slices)
Trader Joe’s Vegan Mozzarella Shreds
Kite Hill ricotta
Kite Hill almond cream cheese
Trader Joe’s vegan cream cheese
Silk coconut yogurt
Kite Hill almond yogurt
Forager cashew and drinkable yogurt
Heavy Cream/Half and Half Full-fat coconut milk (from a can)
Trader Joe’s Coconut Creamer
Califa Dairy Free Better Half
Chocolate Chips Whole Foods (365) Vegan Chocolate Chips
Trader Joe’s Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips
Enjoy Life Chocolate Chips
Dark chocolate (cut into chunks)
Egg Soft tofu
Banana
Applesauce
Flax egg
Soaked chia seeds
Peanut butter
Egg White Aquafaba—the water in a can of garbanzo
beans!  
Honey Agave syrup
Maple syrup

Gluten Free Substitutes

FlourAP (all purpose):
Cup4Cup
King Arthur Flour
Krusteaz  

Other mixable flours:
Buckwheat flour
Coconut flour
Almond flour
Brown rice flour
White rice flour
Tapioca starch/flour
Potato starch
Arrowroot flour
Chickpea flour
Corn meal
Quinoa flour
GF Oat flour (Be careful with this one—oats are
naturally gluten free, but are often
cross-contaminated. Don’t buy it unless it says gluten
free. Or, better yet, make your own!)
PastaBarilla‘s corn and rice
Ronzoni‘s white rice, brown rice, corn, and quinoa blend
Trader Joe’s brown rice, lentil, or black bean
Banza‘s chickpea
Ancient Harvest‘s chickpea, lentil, or quinoa and corn
BreadLettuce (get on board with some lettuce wraps!)
Corn tortillas (I suggest finding a local brand)
Trader Joe’s gluten free bagels, hot dog and hamburger
buns, sliced white and multigrain bread

Note: This is a working list of my favorite substitutions and brands. There are many other brands out there! As I discover more, I will add and edit!
Last updated: June 19, 2019

Published by Colleen N

I am a former teacher, new writer and editor, and passionate culinary experimenter. I am gluten and lactose intolerant (and also can't eat potatoes—ridiculous, right?) and am relentless about making eating the best part of my day. Other passions include hiking, wine, noodles, reading, cats, and training for triathlons.

One thought on ““So … what can you eat?”

Leave a comment